GMA 7 News and ABS-CBN’s separate statements on their respective coverage of the bus siege at Quirino Grandstand

GMA News: We are reviewing how we covered the hostage crisis

posted on its website on 08/25/2010 | 10:29 PM


Immediately after our live coverage of the hostage taking and its bloody outcome last Monday, we reviewed how we covered the situation.

We are now taking a second look at our existing policies and processes to determine how these can be improved and how we can fill up what is lacking.

At the end of this review, we will come up with a revised set of rules and guidelines to be implemented during situations that pose risks to our personnel and to the public.

We are also open to dialogue with authorities on how we can work together in situations like this in the interest of the safety of the public, especially hostages.


Agad-agad matapos ang aming live coverage ng hostage taking at sa madugong pagwawakas nito noong Lunes, sinimulang suriin ng GMA News ang aming naging paraan ng pagbabalita ng naturang insidente.

Pinag-aaralan naming muli ang kasulukuyang mga patakaran at palakad upang malaman kung paano pa ito mapabubuti at mapunan ang mga kakulangan.

Sa pagtatapos ng pagsusuring ito, bubuo ang GMA News and Public Affairs ng mga bagong patakaran na ipatutupad sa mga coverage na sadyang may bantang panganib sa aming mga news and public affairs coverage teams at maging sa publiko.

Bukas ang GMA News na makipag-dialogo sa mga otoridad upang mapag-usapan ang pinakamabuting paraaan upang mapangalagaan ang kaligtasan ng publiko, lalo ng mga hostage. – GMANews.TV


by ANC 24/7 on Thursday, August 26, 2010 at 12:21am

posted on

Media’s job is to tell the story, but no story is worth even one life.

We will always cooperate with authorities in trying to resolve complex situations like the Aug 23 hostage crisis.

If the government had called for a news blackout, ABS-CBN would have supported it.

We are done with an initial assessment of our coverage and continue to review our policies.

We exercised self-restraint on Monday:

1.  We refused to air the hostage taker’s threats live about a 3 pm deadline to avoid fuelling public fear.

2.  We refused to air the hostage taker’s interview until after negotiations were finished.

3.  We refused to be part of hostage negotiations.

4.  All throughout the day and until the first shots were aired, we kept our cameras 400 meters away from the bus, giving us shaky video that viewers complained about.  Our teams never crossed the police line.

5.  Although we had access to members of the police reaction team, we held back interviews which could compromise their plans and/or location.

6.  After the police tried to arrest the hostage taker’s brother, our team physically stepped back to comply with police request.

7.  After the assault began, we tried to limit our shots to avoid showing police movements.  We stayed with extreme close-ups or wide shots.

8.  We immediately complied when police asked us to turn off our lights explaining the grainy shots viewers complained about.

9.  We avoided tampering with evidence at crime scene.  Instead, we asked Soco to shoot the video instead of entering the bus ourselves.

This wasn’t enough.

We acknowledge airing a report that detailed the position of the police during the assault.

During the arrest of Gregorio Mendoza, we considered pulling away from the coverage but a man was crying for help.

In other countries around the world, governments set the ground rules for situations like this.  One network cannot unilaterally declare a news blackout.  Press freedom issues take a back seat during situations like this – where the government already has the power to define the terms to media.

We are taking the public’s views to heart.  Monday’s tragic events triggered intense soul-searching for us.  Such is the irony of a profession that wields so much power but relies entirely on self-doubt to gain — and keep — its credibility.

We ask our broadcast colleagues to join us in an industry review.  Let us unite and work together to put in place measures to collectively decide when we stop live coverage in the absence of government presence of mind.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s